This post contains remaining parts of my DFG Heisenberg grant final report, by now long submitted and accepted by the DFG. I hope it will be of use, in particular to future DFG grant candidates. The text also somewhat explains why I'm fed up with academia, Regensburg, and physics right now (in no particular order and to varying degrees). The first part of the report can be found in a previous post. Some personal information has been redacted.
Qualification, career, …
During the Heisenberg period 2021-2026, submitted applications for professorships resulted in 8 invitations for presentation and discussion: [...]
A recurrent topic over all my years in academia was that appointment procedures for professorships either failed or that positions were handed to local Emmy Noether, Heisenberg, Juniorprofessor, etc. candidates – much more than expected from past times when the spectre of unwanted “Hausberufung” (in-house appointment) was looming over such events. From that point of view it was equally disappointing that, once I applied for a position in Regensburg, I was immediately told by a member of the appointment commission that my application would be sorted out for exactly that reason. When I spoke to an external member of the appointment commission for that professorship, that external member did not even know that I had applied for the position. In parallel, somewhat doubtful direct appointments to professorships took place in the department.
Further frustration originated from the fact that the Regensburg physics department decided to rewrite their internal regulations such that even after 6 years of Privatdozentur (senior lecturer with habilitation) they only award the title of Außerordentlicher Professor (associated professor, a title without salary) to candidates with a permanent university position. My corresponding petition never received any written response, only oral comment that this is not done anymore. The motivation behind all this is unclear, but it certainly does not make Regensburg more attractive to (somewhat) junior scientists.
A four-eyes career conversation with Mr. Dean of the Faculty resulted in charming comments such as “the best we can do is half an E13 position in the experimental collection maintenance of the undergraduate lectures in a year or so, maybe you could do some research on the side there” and “as a Heisenberg you are an academic legacy problem” (the original German term was “akademische Altlast”). Plus remarks like “we are not going to hand out any (even unpaid) teaching assignments (“Lehraufträge”) to an external Privatdozent anymore, so you’ll lose that title anyway soon for lack of teaching.”
The final cherry on top was then getting berated by another influential senior faculty member about producing insufficient results and being unable to supervise – which is pretty thick coming from someone who barely finds any MSc students, having a reputation among students for erratic grading there. To quote a colleague from Regensburg with permanent employment who should probably stay anonymous, “Der professorale Dünkel ist stark in der Fakultät” (roughly translated, the professorial sense of self-importance is tantamount in the department).
With all these experiences as background, I strongly recommend to anyone with a grant such as DFG Emmy Noether or Heisenberg not to join the Regensburg physics department, but go somewhere else. You and your work will be valued more, and that by far compensates for any Regensburg “excellence”. [...]
Teaching and scientific events
With already significant teaching experience, I decided to mostly focus on research and supervision during the Heisenberg period – with the exception of a “Low Temperature Physics” course where the usual lecturer was on sabbatical. Regarding scientific events, I had requested a moderate amount of funding for a workshop on inorganic nanotubes in [...], which would have fitted quite well as add-on to the workshops of SFB 1277. This was however declined – accordingly, it also did not have priority for me anymore either.
Perspective
I enjoyed university research and teaching as well as working with students, establishing a research group, quantum device fabrication, and complex measurements very much. With the “orderly shutdown” of the group comes that still some students need to graduate and that some results will still be written up and submitted for publication (at the time of this report two papers have been submitted and another two or three might follow); however, I have cleared out my office the day of the end of my employment contract.
Out of a certain stubbornness, I will keep teaching my 2SWS per year Titellehre for now – as confirmed by the faculty administration, a teaching appointment (“Lehrauftrag”) is legally not required for that, and as a consequence the students will be treated to a block course “How to write a thesis, present a talk, …” in October. However, after over 15 years in Regensburg I have learned that being nice, friendly, cooperative, and helpful might get you friendly smiles and occasional money there but not any sustainable support, and that the Regensburg physics system prefers “junior scientists” to be subordinates, not colleagues. Of course someone who does not have the visible backing of his current university immediately also has a weaker position when applying elsewhere.
There’s a lot more I could write, but that would go beyond scope and purpose of this report. Anyway, it is now time to make a bonfire out of lecture notes, to go out into the wide world, and to do something entirely new. Which, barring big surprises, most likely will not involve physics or a university anymore.
Thanks to Duong Thi Hai Yen on vecteezy.com for the tomato.


